Outdoor cooking

Griddle vs. Gas Grill vs. Pellet Grill

Updated November 15, 2026 · About 11 minutes

These three machines are often lumped together as “grills.” They are not the same tool. A gas grill sears and roasts over open grates. A flat-top griddle is a giant outdoor skillet. A pellet grill is closer to a set-it-and-hold smoker that can also roast. Buying the wrong one usually means you cook around its limits for years.

What you are actually trying to cook

If you mostly cook…Start with
Steaks, chicken pieces, vegetables with grill marks, weeknight burgersA propane gas grill
Smashed burgers, fried eggs, fajitas, fried rice, pancakes for a crowdA flat-top griddle
Brisket, pork shoulder, ribs, or long roasts you want to start and monitor from a phoneA pellet grill

A household that entertains will sometimes want two of these. That is rational. Owning all three before you know which style you cook every week is not.

The gas grill: weeknight workhorse

Lifestyle photo of the Weber Genesis E-315

Weber Genesis E-315 3-Burner Propane Grill (1500010)

A three-burner propane grill with the even-heat reputation people buy a Genesis for. A “buy once” shape that photographs well on a modern patio.

Recently listed at $799.00 (as of November 15, 2026; always recheck the live price)

View the Weber Genesis E-315 product page AFFILIATE_LINK_TODO

A three-burner Genesis-class grill is the default “I want dinner on the table” machine. You get zone control (one burner off for indirect heat), a lid for roasting, and a familiar grate. Cast-iron or porcelain-coated grates hold heat for a better sear than thin wire grates. Budget a cover, a grate brush or scraper you actually use, and a drip-tray habit, or the cart will remind you.

Skip a large gas grill if you truly never cook with direct heat, or if you have no space for a propane tank. In those cases a pellet grill or a smaller portable may be the better first buy.

The griddle: the outdoor skillet

Lifestyle photo of the Blackstone 4-burner griddle

Blackstone 4-Burner Liquid Propane Outdoor Griddle with Hood (8093917)

A large propane flat-top with a hood — built for smashed burgers, fajitas, and weekend brunch rather than classic grill marks.

Recently listed at $498.99 (as of November 15, 2026; always recheck the live price)

View the Blackstone 4-burner griddle product page AFFILIATE_LINK_TODO

A four-burner Blackstone with a hood is for volume and for foods that would fall through grates. The hood helps with wind and with melting cheese; it does not turn the griddle into a smoker. Plan on a seasoning routine, a good scraper, and a place to store a squeeze bottle of oil. If you hate the idea of maintaining a steel cooktop, this is not your personality, no matter how good smashed burgers look in photos.

The pellet grill: wood fire with a thermostat

Lifestyle photo of the Traeger Pro 575

Traeger Pro 575 Wi-Fi Pellet Grill (TFB57GZE)

A Wi-Fi pellet grill and smoker for set-it-and-check-it cooks: wood-fired flavor with app temperature control.

Recently listed at $599.99 (as of November 15, 2026; always recheck the live price)

View the Traeger Pro 575 product page AFFILIATE_LINK_TODO

The Traeger Pro 575 is the “set a temperature and walk away” example, with Wi-Fi so you can check the cook without hovering. Pellets cost money and need to stay dry. The flavor is wood, not a hard gas-grill sear. If what you really want is a Sunday steak with hatch marks, a Genesis-style gas grill will make you happier. If what you want is a pork shoulder that holds 225°F while you do something else, the pellet grill is the one that matches the job.

Space, fuel, and neighbors

Measure the pad, the lid-open height, and the clearance from siding. Propane needs a tank you can swap or refill. Pellets need a dry bin. A griddle needs a little more horizontal space than people expect because the side shelves are part of the workflow. If you are already planning a built-in island, read the outdoor kitchen guide before you buy a freestanding cart you will later try to drop into a cabinet it does not fit.