Outdoor cooking
These three machines are often lumped together as “grills.” They are not the same tool. A gas grill sears and roasts over open grates. A flat-top griddle is a giant outdoor skillet. A pellet grill is closer to a set-it-and-hold smoker that can also roast. Buying the wrong one usually means you cook around its limits for years.
What you are actually trying to cook
| If you mostly cook… | Start with |
|---|---|
| Steaks, chicken pieces, vegetables with grill marks, weeknight burgers | A propane gas grill |
| Smashed burgers, fried eggs, fajitas, fried rice, pancakes for a crowd | A flat-top griddle |
| Brisket, pork shoulder, ribs, or long roasts you want to start and monitor from a phone | A pellet grill |
A household that entertains will sometimes want two of these. That is rational. Owning all three before you know which style you cook every week is not.
The gas grill: weeknight workhorse
Weber Genesis E-315 3-Burner Propane Grill (1500010)
A three-burner propane grill with the even-heat reputation people buy a Genesis for. A “buy once” shape that photographs well on a modern patio.
Recently listed at $799.00 (as of November 15, 2026; always recheck the live price)
View the Weber Genesis E-315 product page AFFILIATE_LINK_TODO
A three-burner Genesis-class grill is the default “I want dinner on the table” machine. You get zone control (one burner off for indirect heat), a lid for roasting, and a familiar grate. Cast-iron or porcelain-coated grates hold heat for a better sear than thin wire grates. Budget a cover, a grate brush or scraper you actually use, and a drip-tray habit, or the cart will remind you.
Skip a large gas grill if you truly never cook with direct heat, or if you have no space for a propane tank. In those cases a pellet grill or a smaller portable may be the better first buy.
The griddle: the outdoor skillet
Blackstone 4-Burner Liquid Propane Outdoor Griddle with Hood (8093917)
A large propane flat-top with a hood — built for smashed burgers, fajitas, and weekend brunch rather than classic grill marks.
Recently listed at $498.99 (as of November 15, 2026; always recheck the live price)
View the Blackstone 4-burner griddle product page AFFILIATE_LINK_TODO
A four-burner Blackstone with a hood is for volume and for foods that would fall through grates. The hood helps with wind and with melting cheese; it does not turn the griddle into a smoker. Plan on a seasoning routine, a good scraper, and a place to store a squeeze bottle of oil. If you hate the idea of maintaining a steel cooktop, this is not your personality, no matter how good smashed burgers look in photos.
The pellet grill: wood fire with a thermostat
Traeger Pro 575 Wi-Fi Pellet Grill (TFB57GZE)
A Wi-Fi pellet grill and smoker for set-it-and-check-it cooks: wood-fired flavor with app temperature control.
Recently listed at $599.99 (as of November 15, 2026; always recheck the live price)
View the Traeger Pro 575 product page AFFILIATE_LINK_TODO
The Traeger Pro 575 is the “set a temperature and walk away” example, with Wi-Fi so you can check the cook without hovering. Pellets cost money and need to stay dry. The flavor is wood, not a hard gas-grill sear. If what you really want is a Sunday steak with hatch marks, a Genesis-style gas grill will make you happier. If what you want is a pork shoulder that holds 225°F while you do something else, the pellet grill is the one that matches the job.
Space, fuel, and neighbors
Measure the pad, the lid-open height, and the clearance from siding. Propane needs a tank you can swap or refill. Pellets need a dry bin. A griddle needs a little more horizontal space than people expect because the side shelves are part of the workflow. If you are already planning a built-in island, read the outdoor kitchen guide before you buy a freestanding cart you will later try to drop into a cabinet it does not fit.